GuideAsk Conyer
Answers for “roof replacement cost”
24 answers from our guides, FAQs and service pages.
Guides & Articles4
Frequently Asked Questions10
View All FAQsHow much does a roof replacement cost in Middle Tennessee?
Most asphalt shingle roof replacements in Middle Tennessee land between $12,000 and $28,000, depending on the size and pitch of the roof, the shingle line you choose, how many layers need to be torn off, and details like decking repairs, ventilation, and flashing.
Be careful comparing quotes on price alone. A low bid usually means corners are being cut somewhere you can't see — skipped ice-and-water barrier, reused flashing, or uncertified installers, which can also void your shingle warranty. As a GAF Master Elite contractor we install complete roofing systems to manufacturer spec, which is what makes the strongest warranties available.
The only way to get a real number is an inspection and measurement. Ours are free, documented with photos, and come with a written itemized estimate — no pressure, no games.
How long does a roof replacement take?
Most residential roof replacements in Middle Tennessee are done in one day — two for larger or steeper homes, or when decking repairs turn up under the old shingles.
The bigger timeline question is scheduling: from signed contract to crew on the roof is typically one to three weeks depending on season and material availability, and faster for emergencies. Insurance restorations add the claim timeline up front, which usually runs two to six weeks depending on your carrier.
We protect landscaping, run magnetic sweeps for nails, and haul away every scrap of the old roof. The only evidence we were there should be the new roof.
How does roof financing work?
Simple version: you pick a payment that fits your budget instead of writing one big check.
After your free inspection and estimate, we'll walk you through the financing options available for your project — typically fixed monthly payments across a range of terms, with promotional options depending on the current programs. Checking what you qualify for doesn't affect your credit score; a hard pull only happens if you accept an offer.
Financing also pairs well with insurance work — some homeowners finance their deductible or upgrades (like stepping up a shingle line or adding gutter guards) while insurance covers the storm damage itself.
How do I avoid storm-chaser roofing scams?
After every big Middle Tennessee storm, out-of-state trucks appear. Some are legitimate; many are not. Red flags:
- Door-knockers demanding you sign today "to hold your spot in line"
- Offers to waive or eat your deductible (illegal — and the clearest tell there is)
- No local address you can visit, no Tennessee license number, out-of-state plates
- Pressure to sign an assignment-of-benefits or a vague "contingency agreement" before any inspection report
- Cash-only or big deposits up front
Protect yourself: verify the license, ask for the physical office address, read recent local reviews, and get the inspection findings in writing with photos before signing anything. We've been here, we'll be here — 2002 New Deal Potts Rd in Portland isn't going anywhere.
What warranty comes with a new GAF roof?
Two layers of protection:
- Materials: GAF shingles carry a Lifetime limited warranty on the shingles themselves when installed as part of a qualifying system.
- Workmanship: Because we're a GAF Master Elite contractor, we can register enhanced system warranties up to the Golden Pledge® Warranty — which includes up to 25 years of workmanship coverage inspected and backed by GAF directly.
That second layer is the one most homeowners never get. A typical contractor's "workmanship warranty" is only as good as the company behind it; a Golden Pledge is honored by GAF even if the installing contractor is gone. We register every eligible warranty and hand you the paperwork before we're done.
What’s the best time of year to replace a roof in Tennessee?
Any season works — shingle manufacturers rate installation down to about 40°F, and we roof year-round.
Fall brings the most predictable weather and is our busiest season (book ahead). Spring is great, dodging around storm season. Summer works fine; crews just start at first light. Winter installs are common and sometimes come with faster scheduling since demand drops.
The truthful answer: the best time to replace a roof is before it fails. A planned replacement in January beats an emergency in the middle of April storm season every single time.
Metal roof vs. architectural shingles — which is better?
Both are excellent when installed right; they solve different problems.
Architectural shingles (like GAF Timberline HDZ) cost roughly half as much installed, look right on most Middle Tennessee homes, install in a day, and carry outstanding warranties. For most homeowners, they're the sweet spot.
Standing-seam metal costs significantly more up front but lasts 40–60 years, sheds storms beautifully, and can lower cooling bills. It makes the most sense if this is your forever home, or on farmhouse/modern styles where the look is the point.
We install both, so you'll get a straight comparison for your specific house instead of a pitch for whatever we happen to sell.
Should I repair or replace my roof?
Honest rule of thumb: repair when the roof is under ~15 years old and the damage is localized — a leak around a flashing, a few wind-blown shingles, a puncture. Replace when the roof is nearing the end of its lifespan, damage is widespread, repairs are recurring, or a storm compromised enough of it that insurance is already involved.
The math matters too: three $800 repairs on a 19-year-old roof is worse than putting that money toward the replacement you'll need soon anyway.
We quote both paths when both are viable, with photos of what we found, so the decision is yours with real information. We do plenty of repairs — we're not a "replacement only" shop.
How long do roofs last in Middle Tennessee?
Rules of thumb for our climate — hot humid summers, freeze-thaw winters, and real storm exposure:
- 3-tab asphalt shingles: 15–20 years
- Architectural shingles (e.g. GAF Timberline HDZ): 22–28 years
- Premium/designer shingles: 25–30+ years
- Standing-seam metal: 40–60 years
- Commercial TPO: 20–30 years
Storms shorten all of these — a roof that's "only" 12 years old can absolutely be done after a bad hail season. Past 15 years, an annual inspection is cheap insurance; past 20, start planning the replacement on your schedule instead of the weather's.
Can a roofer waive or "cover" my insurance deductible in Tennessee?
No — and any roofer who offers to is committing insurance fraud and asking you to participate in it.
Tennessee law requires homeowners to pay their deductible, and contractors who "eat the deductible" make up the difference somewhere: inflated invoices to the carrier, skipped materials, or shortcuts on labor. It's also the single most reliable marker of a storm-chasing operation that won't exist when your warranty needs honoring.
We'll help you get every legitimate dollar your policy owes you — real damage, documented thoroughly, scoped fully (including code-required items adjusters sometimes miss). That's how you maximize a claim honestly.
Services6
- Roof ReplacementComplete tear-off and replacement with GAF systems, installed by President’s Club crews and backed by warranties most…
- Insurance Roof ReplacementWe document the damage, meet your adjuster on the roof, and handle the claim from first call to final inspection.
- Roof CoatingRestoration coatings that extend a sound flat roof by a decade — at a fraction of tear-off cost.
- RoofingReplacement, repair, metal, flat, inspections, and maintenance — every roofing service we offer across Middle Tennessee.
- TPO RoofingHeat-welded thermoplastic membrane — bright white, energy-efficient, and the dominant choice for new commercial flat…
- Classic Rib Metal RoofingExposed-fastener panel roofing — durable, economical, and the right answer for barns, shops, and outbuildings.
Pages4
- Roofing GuidesHow roofing systems work, what goes wrong, and how to judge a contractor’s proposal.
- Cost GuidesReal Middle Tennessee pricing ranges, and the variables that move them.
- Our StoryHow Conyer Roofing & Exteriors started, and what we have refused to change since.
- Learning CenterGuides, cost breakdowns, insurance walkthroughs, and comparisons — everything we know, written down.
Talk to a real person
Our Portland, TN office picks up — no script, no pressure.
(615) 802-1032Or ask our assistant — it has read every guide and answers in plain English.



